January 2012

JFP 1/12: US abuse viral; Clinton bogus Iran claim; UN busted on Haiti cholera

Just Foreign Policy News, January 12, 2012
US abuse viral; Clinton bogus Iran claim; UN busted on Haiti cholera


Support the Work of Just Foreign Policy
Your support helps us to educate Americans about U.S. foreign policy and create opportunities for Americans to advocate for a foreign policy that is more just. Help us press for an end to the war in Afghanistan and spread opposition to a new war with Iran,
http://www.justforeignpolicy.org/donate

Go Straight to the News Summary

I) Actions and Featured Articles

Donate to Place an Ad in The Hill to Prevent War on Iran
CodePink is placing an anti-Iran-war ad to coincide with the AIPAC meeting in Washington March 2-6.
https://codepink.salsalabs.com/o/424/p/salsa/donation/common/public/?donate_page_KEY=7465
More info: http://www.occupyaipac.org/

Glenn Greenwald: Iran and the Terrorism game
In the few venues which denounced as "Terrorism" the ongoing assassinations of Iranian scientists, there was intense backlash against the invocation of that term.
http://www.salon.com/2012/01/12/iran_and_the_terrorism_game/

Ralph Nader: Iran: The Neocons Are At It Again
The neocons who persuaded Bush to "lie their way into invading Iraq" are beating the drums of war to attack Iran. It is past time for the American citizenry to wake up and declare: Iran will not be an Iraq Redux!

Tags:

JFP 1/11: IAEA says Fordo under inspection; NPR responds to criticism

Just Foreign Policy News, January 11, 2012
IAEA says Fordo under inspection; NPR responds to criticism


Support the Work of Just Foreign Policy
Your support helps us to educate Americans about U.S. foreign policy and create opportunities for Americans to advocate for a foreign policy that is more just. Help us press for an end to the war in Afghanistan and spread opposition to a new war with Iran,
http://www.justforeignpolicy.org/donate

Go Straight to the News Summary

I) Actions and Featured Articles

Update on request for corrections on Iran nuclear program reporting to PBS, NPR
We sent out an alert this morning asking people to contact PBS and NPR to object to their reporting on Iran's nuclear program. That alert is here:

Tell PBS, NPR: No proof Iran has a nuclear weapons program
http://www.justforeignpolicy.org/act/misleadingoniran

With respect to NPR, we objected to their reporting that the goal of the U.S. was "to convince Iran to give up a nuclear weapons program," since that implies that Iran has a nuclear weapons program to give up, and the question of whether Iran has a nuclear weapons program is in dispute.

The alert also asked people to contact PBS to complain concerning NewsHour's selective editing, as noted by FAIR, of Defense Secretary Panetta's remarks to Face the Nation, excluding his statement: "Are they trying to develop a nuclear weapon? No," and then using his remarks to imply the opposite.

Tags:

JFP 1/10: NYT Public Editor says NYT should correct account of IAEA report

Just Foreign Policy News, January 10, 2012
NYT Public Editor says NYT should correct account of IAEA report


Support the Work of Just Foreign Policy
Your support helps us to educate Americans about U.S. foreign policy and create opportunities for Americans to advocate for a foreign policy that is more just. Help us press for an end to the war in Afghanistan and spread opposition to a new war with Iran,
http://www.justforeignpolicy.org/donate

Go Straight to the News Summary

I) Actions and Featured Articles

NYT Public Editor says NYT should correct account of IAEA report
On the fundamental issues in dispute - the NYT's characterization of the IAEA report was wrong and the NYT should make a clear correction - Arthur Brisbane comes down on the side of the complainants:
[...]
In other words, the IAEA moved much closer with this report toward stating absolutely that Iran is pursuing a nuclear bomb. Yet the fact that the agency has stopped short of such a finding remains significant. Readers complaining about the Jan. 5 article believe The Times should avoid closing the gap with a shorthand phrase that says the IAEA thinks Iran's program "has a military objective."

I think the readers are correct on this. The Times hasn't corrected the story but it should because this is a case of when a shorthand phrase doesn't do justice to a nuanced set of facts. In this case, the distinction between the two is important because the Iranian program has emerged as a possible casus belli.

[...]
-
Times errors: Iran's nukes, SF's voting

Tags:

WaPo: Sneaky Persians Menace Pentagon's Noble Aim to Keep U.S. Troops in Afghanistan Forever

In a front page exposé on January 4, the Washington Post revealed that sneaky Persian agitators are conspiring to thwart the Pentagon's noble aim of keeping 10,000-30,000 U.S. troops in Afghanistan on "non-permanent," "non-U.S." bases after "all foreign troops are supposed to be withdrawn" in 2014, just as these sneaky Persians conspired to thwart the Pentagon's noble aim of keeping U.S. troops in Iraq.

The Post story is quite instructive, even if it is not exactly "news" in the common sense of the term. It presents the world from the point of view of diehard Pentagon revanchists who want to keep US troops in Muslim countries forever against the will of the majority of Americans and against the will of the majority of people who live in these countries. It presents this diehard Pentagon revanchist view as if there were no interests in the world besides those of Pentagon revanchists and wily Persian agitators, such as the interests of the majority of people who happen to live in the United States, Afghanistan, and Iraq. Of course, in the world view of the diehard Pentagon revanchist, the concerns of these mere residents are largely irrelevant, if they have no military implications. How many divisions do these mere residents control? These mere residents are just pawns in a game of Pentagon-sneaky Persian chess.

It is a story, moreover, that is spectacularly contradicted by the Post's own previous reporting, as well as that of other major American newspapers.

The story informs us:

 

JFP 1/6: Judy Miller Alert! NYT Misleads About Iran's Nuclear Program

Just Foreign Policy News, January 6, 2012
Judy Miller Alert! The New York Times Misleads About Iran's Nuclear Program

Support the Work of Just Foreign Policy
Your support helps us to educate Americans about U.S. foreign policy and create opportunities for Americans to advocate for a foreign policy that is more just. Help us press for an end to the war in Afghanistan and spread opposition to a new war with Iran,
http://www.justforeignpolicy.org/donate

Go Straight to the News Summary

I) Actions and Featured Articles

Judy Miller Alert! The New York Times Misleads About Iran's Nuclear Program
It's deja vu all over again. AIPAC is trying to trick America into another catastrophic war with a Middle Eastern country on behalf of the Likud Party's colonial ambitions, and the New York Times is misleading its readers about allegations that said country is developing "weapons of mass destruction."
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/robert-naiman/ny-times-iran_b_1189407.html

FAIR: NYT Misleads Readers on Iran Crisis
Paper disappears some inaccurate reporting
http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=4454

ACTION:
Contact the New York Times and ask it to investigate and explain the editing of the January 5 front-page article, and to correct both misleading assertions about Iran and nuclear weapons.
CONTACT:
Public Editor Arthur Brisbane
Email: public@nytimes.com
Phone: 212-556-7652

Tags:

Judy Miller Alert! The New York Times is Lying About Iran's Nuclear Program

It's deja vu all over again. AIPAC is trying to trick America into another catastrophic war with a Middle Eastern country on behalf of the Likud Party's colonial ambitions, and the New York Times is lying about allegations that said country is developing "weapons of mass destruction."

In an article attributed to Steven Erlanger on January 4 ("Europe Takes Bold Step Toward a Ban on Iranian Oil "), this paragraph appeared:

 

The threats from Iran, aimed both at the West and at Israel, combined with a recent assessment by the International Atomic Energy Agency that Iran's nuclear program has a military objective, is becoming an important issue in the American presidential campaign. [my emphasis]

The claim that there is "a recent assessment by the International Atomic Energy Agency that Iran's nuclear program has a military objective" is a lie.

As Washington Post Ombudsman Patrick Pexton noted on December 9,

 

But the IAEA report does not say Iran has a bomb, nor does it say it is building one, only that its multiyear effort pursuing nuclear technology is sophisticated and broad enough that it could be consistent with building a bomb.

Indeed, if you try now to find the offending paragraph on the New York Times website, you can't. They took it down. But there is no note, like there is supposed to be, acknowledging that they changed the article, and that there was something wrong with it before. Sneaky, huh?

But you can still find the original here.

JFP 1/5: David Gregory Should Tell Rick Santorum There Are UN Inspectors in Iran

Just Foreign Policy News, January 5, 2012
David Gregory Should Tell Rick Santorum There Are UN Inspectors in Iran


Support the Work of Just Foreign Policy
Your support helps us to educate Americans about U.S. foreign policy and create opportunities for Americans to advocate for a foreign policy that is more just. Help us press for an end to the war in Afghanistan and spread opposition to a new war with Iran,
http://www.justforeignpolicy.org/donate

Go Straight to the News Summary

I) Actions and Featured Articles

David Gregory Should Tell Rick Santorum There Are UN Inspectors in Iran
Rick Santorum is running as the "more AIPAC than thou" candidate. But David Gregory wants people to think of him as a "journalist." We can hold David Gregory to a higher standard. Politicians will say whatever they can get away with, but journalists have an obligation to correct serious misstatements of fact.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/robert-naiman/david-gregory-should-tell_b_1186410.html
If you agree, you can write to Meet the Press here:
meetthepressquestions@nbcuni.com

Heather Hurlburt: Pentagon Strategy Review: Why It Matters
2012 and 2013 Pentagon spending will represent the first real declines in military spending in more than a decade; but the total 8% cut envisaged is less than the Reagan defense builddown of the 1980s. Even if the more dramatic cuts in the Budget Control Act sequester were enacted, they would only return the Pentagon to 2007 levels.

Tags:

David Gregory Should Tell Rick Santorum There Are UN Inspectors in Iran

Rick Santorum is running as the "more AIPAC than thou" candidate. But David Gregory wants people to think of him as a "journalist." We can hold David Gregory to a higher standard.

On Sunday, Republican Presidential Rick Santorum told David Gregory on NBC's "Meet the Press" that, unlike President Obama, he would "be saying to the Iranians, you either open up those [nuclear] facilities, you begin to dismantle them and, and make them available to inspectors, or we will degrade those facilities through airstrikes and make it very public that we are doing that."

David Gregory did not challenge Santorum's statement. But Gregory knows - or should know - that Iran's nuclear facilities are already under the inspection of the International Atomic Energy Agency. Politicians will say whatever they can get away with, but journalists have an obligation to correct serious misstatements of fact.

Of course, one can try to come up with excuses for why David Gregory didn't correct the record. Let's consider some potential excuses, and why they are no good.

"Journalists can't correct everything candidates say." This was a one-on-one interview, and the topic of discussion was Iran's nuclear program, and Rick Santorum's claims that he would be tougher than President Obama in confronting Iran about its nuclear program. Is there another context where it would be more appropriate for David Gregory to correct the record about what is known about Iran's nuclear program?

JFP 1/4: Obama can't stop Israeli attack? Markets rattled by Iran tensions

Just Foreign Policy News, January 4, 2012
Obama can't stop Israeli attack? Markets rattled by Iran tensions

Support the Work of Just Foreign Policy
Your support helps us to educate Americans about U.S. foreign policy and create opportunities for Americans to advocate for a foreign policy that is more just. Help us press for an end to the war in Afghanistan and spread opposition to a new war with Iran,
http://www.justforeignpolicy.org/donate

Go Straight to the News Summary

I) Actions and Featured Articles

In Iowa, Peace Voters Turned Out for Ron Paul in Higher Numbers Than Anticipated
Ron Paul didn't win the Iowa caucus, but it wasn't because peace voters didn't show up. Indeed, peace voters did show up, in higher numbers than anticipated; and they voted for Ron Paul, in higher numbers than anticipated. Going forward, this means that there is a substantial group of voters who is willing to vote for a peace candidate in a Republican primary or caucus -- if they have a peace candidate to vote for. And this result will be seen not just in future Presidential primaries and caucuses, but in Congressional races -- if there is a peace candidate to vote for. If you're a person that cares about working with Congress to end wars, prevent new ones, and stop the Pentagon from hogging so much of our national resources, this is a very big deal.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/robert-naiman/in-iowa-peace-voters-turn_b_1184012.html

Institute for Public Accuracy: JFP responds to press coverage of Santorum threat to bomb Iran

Tags:

JFP 1/3: Taliban agree to Qatar office; Pentagon to give up two war capacity

Just Foreign Policy News, January 3, 2012
Taliban agree to Qatar office; Pentagon to give up two war capacity

Support the Work of Just Foreign Policy
Your support helps us to educate Americans about U.S. foreign policy and create opportunities for Americans to advocate for a foreign policy that is more just. Help us press for an end to the war in Afghanistan and spread opposition to a new war with Iran,
http://www.justforeignpolicy.org/donate

Go Straight to the News Summary

I) Actions and Featured Articles

JFP responds to press coverage of Santorum threat to bomb Iran
"Rick Santorum told NBC's David Gregory on 'Meet the Press' that, unlike President Obama, he would 'be saying to the Iranians, you either open up those [nuclear] facilities, you begin to dismantle them and, and make them available to inspectors, or we will degrade those facilities through airstrikes and make it very public that we are doing that.' Mr. Gregory did not challenge this statement. Surely Mr. Gregory knows that Iran's nuclear facilities are already under the inspection of the International Atomic Energy Agency. Politicians will say whatever they can get away with but journalists have an obligation to correct serious misstatements of fact.'"
http://www.accuracy.org/release/26333/

Juan Cole: Will his New Sanctions on Iran Cost Obama the Presidency?

Tags: