Kinzer: Surge Diplomacy, Not Troops, in Afghanistan

USA Today reports that Gen. McKiernan - top U.S. commander in Afghanistan - “has asked the Pentagon for more than 20,000 soldiers, Marines and airmen” to augment U.S. forces. McKiernan says U.S. troop levels of 55,000 to 60,000 in Afghanistan will be needed for “at least three or four more years.” He added: “If we put these additional forces in here, it’s going to be for the next few years. It’s not a temporary increase of combat strength.”

We should have a vigorous national debate before embarking on this course. Contrary to what one might think from a quick scan of the newspapers, there are knowledgeable voices questioning whether increasing the deployment of U.S. troops to Afghanistan is in our interest, or is in the interest of the Afghan people.

Bestselling author and former longtime New York Times foreign correspondent Stephen Kinzer argues the opposite in this five minute video:


Kinzer argues that sending more U.S. troops is likely to be counterproductive. It’s likely to produce more anger in Afghanistan, and more anger is likely to produce more recruits for the Taliban. A better alternative would surge diplomacy instead, reaching out to people who are now supporting the Taliban.

Al Qaeda and the Taliban are very different forces, argues Kinzer. The Taliban has deep roots in Afghan society. Many of the warlords allied with the Taliban are not fanatic ideologues.

Afghanistan is a place of fluid loyalties, Kinzer notes. A warlord allied with the Taliban may not be anti-American, or if he is today, he need not be tomorrow. We should take advantage of these fluid loyalties, and try to follow the diplomatic solution that Afghans and Afghan leaders are advocating.

Almost all the money in Afghanistan fueling the insurgency comes from the Afghan poppy crop, the source of most of the world’s heroin, Kinzer notes. We’re trying to crush that poppy-growing culture in an impossible way, Kinzer says. Burning and spraying poppy fields will never achieve that goal. All that does is impoverish Afghans and make them more angry at us.

The entire Afghan poppy crop is worth four billion dollars a year. We’re now spending $4 billion a month on our war in Afghanistan. Let’s take one of those months, and buy the entire poppy crop, suggests Kinzer. That way we’re not impoverishing Afghans, we’re putting money in their pockets instead of shooting them and burning down their houses. We’d use some of that to make morphine for medical use and we could burn the rest.

If we continue to act as if there’s a military solution in Afghanistan, we’re just going to get further dragged down into quagmire. There is a way out, Kinzer says. We can follow a much more sophisticated diplomatic and political strategy in a way that will reduce the ability of the Taliban to attract young recruits. What we’re doing now is the opposite, fueling the insurgency. Sending fewer troops to Afghanistan, not more, is needed to stabilize Afghanistan.

If you agree with Stephen Kinzer, why not send a note to that effect to President-elect Obama?

It is also nice to take a look on the demands. It is where leaders can based their targets.

I http://www.ferragamo.com.co/ stood http://www.bottegaveneta-bagsoutlet.com/ in http://www.burberry-handbagsoutlet.com.co/ the http://www.adidasshoescanada.ca/ morning http://www.timberlandshoes.net.co/ the http://www.ray-banocchiali.it/ green http://celtics.nbajersey.us.com/ pasture http://www.scarpe-hoganoutlets.it/ / http://www.oakleys-sunglassoutlet.net/ Eagle http://www.oakley-sunglassess.cc/ dressed http://www.horloges-rolex.nl/ see http://www.michaeljordan.com.de/ that http://www.ok-em.com/ glow http://www.longchamp.com.co/ / http://www.chanelhandbags.net.in/ like http://www.ralphlaurenepolo.com/ a http://www.maccosmetics.net.co/ flying http://www.lululemon-australia.com.au/ blue http://www.michaelkorsbags.com.co/ sky http://www.converse.com.de/ clouds http://knicks.nbajersey.us.com/ / http://www.mcm-backpacks.com/ bring http://www.cheap-oakleyglasses.com/ good http://www.hollister-clothing.in.net/ fortune http://www.thomas-sabo.com.de/ / http://www.christianlouboutinoutlet.net.co/ dusk http://www.oakleys-outletstore.com/ Tibetan http://www.nike-schuhe.com.de/ children http://www.rosherun.co.uk/ home http://mavericks.nbajersey.us.com/ I http://www.lululemonca.ca/ stand http://www.michaelkorsoutlet.ar.com/ tall http://www.ralphlaurens-polo.co.uk/ hill http://www.ralphlaurenoutlet-online.us.com/ / http://www.cheap-omegawatches.com/ rail http://www.adidas-superstar.de/ hope http://colts.nfljersey.us.com/ to http://www.raybans-glasses.com/ repair http://www.swarovski-online-shop.de/ my http://www.hermes-outlet.com.co/ hometown http://www.mk-outletonline.us/ / http://www.pandorajewellery.com.au/ a http://airmax.misblackfriday.com/ dragon http://www.burberry-outletcanada.ca/ mountains http://www.nikeair--max.fr/ / http://www.newoutletonlinemall.com/ well-being http://coach.euro-us.net/ sent http://www.abercrombie-and-fitch.us.com/ to http://www.nike-air-max.com.de/ the http://www.hollisterclothingstore.org/ snow-covered http://www.giuseppezanotti.com.co/ plateau http://www.designer-handbagsoutlet.us.com/ / http://www.burberry-handbagssale.in.net/ it http://cavaliers.nbajersey.us.com/ was http://www.handbagsoutlet.net.co/ a http://vikings.nfljersey.us.com/ magical http://www.oakley--sunglasses.com.au/ day http://www.rayban-sunglassesoutlet.org.uk/ road http://www.soccer-shoesoutlet.com/ / http://www.tommyhilfiger.net.co/ human http://www.fashion-clothes.us.com/ warmth http://www.nike-roshe-run.com.es/ to http://www.oakleyonline.us.com/ the http://www.tiffanyandco-au.com/ frontierI http://www.rolex-watches.cc/ do http://www.moncler-outlet.us.org/ not http://www.lauren-ralph.co.uk/ know http://www.raybanoutlet.ca/ how http://www.ralphlauren-au.com/ many http://www.cheap-baseballbats.us/ times http://www.ugg-boots-australia.com.au/ to http://www.thenorthfacejackets.fr/ revel http://www.abercrombiefitchs.us.com/ in http://www.michael-kors-outlet.us.org/ "Tin http://www.ugg-bootsclearance.com/ Road" http://www.coachoutletstore-online.com.co/ beautiful http://www.nikefree-run.net/ melodies http://www.juicycoutureoutlet.net.co/ and http://www.converses-outlet.com/ wonderful http://www.uhren-shop.com.de/ singing, http://www.coachhandbags2016.us.com/ and http://www.nike-schoenen.co.nl/ the http://www.oakley-glasses2016.com/ front http://patriots.nfljersey.us.com/ surface http://www.timberland-boots.in.net/ of http://nets.nbajersey.us.com/ it http://www.toryburchoutlet-sale.us.com/ is: http://www.ralphslaurenoutlet.us.com/ a http://thunder.nbajersey.us.com/ deep http://www.jordanrelease-dates.us.com/ blue http://mcmbackpack.co-om.com/ sky, http://www.ralphlaurenoutlet.us.com/ the http://www.hollisteronlineshop.com.de/ clouds http://titans.nfljersey.us.com/ drifting http://www.asicsgels.de/ leisurely, http://www.michael-kors.net.co/ distant http://www.nike-huarache.nl/ peaks http://www.truereligion-outlet.com.co/ Sangdankangsang http://www.uggboots.com.de/ quiet http://www.retro-jordans.com/ as http://www.polos-outlet.com/ at http://www.vans-shoes.co.uk/ the http://trailblazers.nbajersey.us.com/ child, http://www.ugg-uggboots.net/ that http://www.air-max-schoenen.nl/ is http://www.nike-free-run.de/ the http://www.coco-chanels.us.org/ eagle http://www.michael-korshandbags.us.org/ fly, http://www.rosheruns.us/ but http://www.ralphslaurens.co.uk/ both http://www.converse.net.co/ peaks, http://www.thenorth-faces.co.uk/ her http://www.pradaoutlet.com.co/ quiet http://www.tocoachoutlet.com/ beauty http://www.burberryonlineshop.de/ of http://michaelkors.co-om.com/ pure, http://www.adidas-schuhe-online.de/ people http://www.longchampoutlet.com.co/ instantly http://www.weddingdressessonline.ca/ awe. http://www.rolexwatches-canada.ca/ A http://www.hogan.com.de/ couple http://www.northfaceoutlet.com.co/ of http://coach-outlet.tumblr.com/ eagle http://www.salvatoreferragamo.in.net/ facing http://www.true-religion.com.co/ the http://www.tomsshoes-outlet.us.com/ sun http://www.salomon-schuhe.com.de/ shining http://www.nfljersey.us.com/ leisurely http://nike.shoesoutlet.cc/ soar, http://www.swarovskijewelry.com.co/ overlooking http://www.kate-spade.gb.net/ idle http://www.uggsoutlet.com.co/ and http://spurs.nbajersey.us.com/ yak http://www.ralphs-laurenoutlet.co.uk/ herd http://www.beats-headphone.com.co/ on http://www.tiffany-und-co.de/ the http://www.nikemercurial.in.net/ prairie. http://www.poloralphlaurenoutlet.net.co/ Jiduo http://www.gucci-outletstore.com/ shiny http://www.mmoncler-outlet.com/ white http://www.ralphlaurenonlineshop.de/ clouds http://www.vibram-fivefingers.us.com/ fixed http://packers.nfljersey.us.com/ on http://grizzlies.nbajersey.us.com/ the http://bengals.nfljersey.us.com/ distant http://www.christianlouboutin.org.uk/ peaks http://www.mcm-handbags.org/ Sangdankangsang, http://www.christian--louboutin.in.net/ near http://www.nike-skor.com.se/ the http://chiefs.nfljersey.us.com/ snow http://www.yogapantscanada.ca/ line http://www.basketballshoes.com.co/ at http://www.the-northface.com.co/ the http://www.longchamp.com.de/ grass http://www.ralphlauren-polos.com.co/ brown, http://www.eyeglasses-outlet.us/ while http://www.tomsoutletonline.net/ foothills http://www.michael-kors-australia.com.au/ grassland http://bucks.nbajersey.us.com/ Qiangtang http://www.burberry-outletonlinesale.in.net/ is http://www.oakleyoutlet.fr/ still http://www.gucci-shoes.net/ a http://www.adidas.org.es/ green, http://www.asics-outlet.us.com/ grazing http://www.wedding--dresses.co.uk/ cattle http://www.the-northface.net.co/ and http://www.nike-rosherun.nl/ sheep http://seahawks.nfljersey.us.com/ scattered http://www.truereligion-outlet.us.org/ on http://airhuarache.shoesoutlet.cc/ the http://www.canadagoosesonline.com/ prairie, http://www.cheap-raybansoutlet.net/ sometimes http://www.beats-by-dre.com.co/ strange http://monsterbeats.co-om.com/ landscape http://www.abercrombie-hollister.nl/ mirage, http://www.soft-ballbats.com/ gave http://www.p90xworkout.us.com/ people http://www.burberry-outlet.uk/ like http://www.airmax-90.org/ drunk http://pelicans.nbajersey.us.com/ like http://www.chiflatiron.net.co/ waking http://kings.nbajersey.us.com/ dream. http://www.tommyhilfigerca.ca/ A http://eagles.nfljersey.us.com/ train http://www.tiffanyandco-ca.ca/ from http://www.longchamp-bags.us.com/ a http://www.toms-shoes.com.co/ distance http://www.new-balance-schuhe.de/ stuff http://www.beatsbydrdrephone.com/ has, http://broncos.nfljersey.us.com/ like http://www.burberry-outletsale.net/ a http://www.michaelkorsoutlet-online.ar.com/ fabulous http://raiders.nfljersey.us.com/ dream. http://www.coachblackfriday.com/ I http://www.oakley-sunglasses.mex.com/ do http://www.jordan-shoes.com.co/ not http://www.uggs.co.nl/ know http://www.nike-factorys.us/ the http://www.cheap-michaelkors.com/ song http://magic.nbajersey.us.com/ too http://www.toms-shoes.net.co/ emotional http://www.soccer-shoes.us.com/ or http://www.nikeair-max.es/ too http://supra.shoesoutlet.cc/ pure http://www.swarovskicrystals.us.com/ picture, http://www.guccishoes.com.co/ when http://www.zxcoachoutlet.com/ I http://www.gucci-shoesoutlet.net/ recovered http://bears.nfljersey.us.com/ from http://www.omega-watches.us.com/ the http://hornets.nbajersey.us.com/ dream, http://www.burberry-outlet.net.co/ it http://www.michaelkorsoutletonline-sale.us.com/ is http://www.nike-maxfr.com/ often http://www.oakley.com.de/ found http://www.polo-ralph-lauren.de/ to http://www.raybans-outlet.us.com/ have http://www.burberry-2016.uk/ eyes http://www.swarovski-australia.com.au/ teared.Sangdankangsang http://www.raybans-sunglasses.cc/ Xuefeng http://www.hollister-abercrombie.com.se/ located http://michaelkors.euro-us.net/ Nyainqentanglha http://www.airmax-2015.org/ middle http://www.tomsoutlet-online.com/ altitude http://www.nikestore.com.de/ of http://www.nikestore.us/ 6590 http://www.tnf-jackets.us.com/ meters, http://www.oakleysframe.com/ is http://www.cheap-jordans.net/ the http://www.uggs-onsale.net/ first http://www.christianlouboutinshoesoutlet.org/ peak http://www.calvin-kleins.us.org/ in http://www.michaelkors.com.se/ northern http://www.chanel-bags.com.co/ Tibet, http://49ers.nfljersey.us.com/ Tibet http://www.pandora-charms.org.uk/ is http://www.rayban-eyeglasses.com/ one http://www.replica-handbags.net.co/ twenty-five http://www.timberlandbootsoutlet.us.com/ highest http://www.pumaonline-shop.de/ mountain, http://www.nikerosherun.us/ is http://www.yoga-pants.net.co/ the http://www.coach-factory.in.net/ appropriate http://www.bottega-venetas.com/ respect http://www.coach-factoryoutlet.net.co/ for http://www.woolrich-clearance.com/ religious http://www.rayban.com.de/ twenty-five http://giants.nfljersey.us.com/ Wonderland http://www.uggs.in.net/ lay http://www.michaelkors-canadaoutlet.ca/ the http://www.rayban.co.nl/ First, http://www.adidas-superstar.nl/ its http://www.airjordans.us/ patron http://www.cheap-rolexwatches.co.uk/ saint http://cowboys.nfljersey.us.com/ is http://www.hermesbirkin-bag.net/ called http://www.coachoutlet-online.com.co/ "Gang http://www.juicycouture.com.co/ Bu http://www.omegarelojes.es/ Sangbu http://www.nike-air-max.com.au/ Yasha" http://www.michael-korssale.us.com/ is http://browns.nfljersey.us.com/ the http://www.abercrombie-andfitch.ca/ almighty http://suns.nbajersey.us.com/ God http://timberwolves.nbajersey.us.com/ to http://www.mcm-bags.us.com/ protect http://www.rb-rm.com/ Dharma. http://www.lululemonoutlet.gb.net/ "Qiangtang" http://saints.nfljersey.us.com/ in http://www.gucci-handbags.in.net/ Tibetan http://www.hollisters-canada.ca/ means http://buccaneers.nfljersey.us.com/ the http://www.supra-shoes.org/ northern http://www.burberrybagsoutlet.net/ highlands, http://www.coach-purseoutlet.net/ is http://rockets.nbajersey.us.com/ one http://pistons.nbajersey.us.com/ of http://www.bcbg-maxazria.ca/ the http://www.nike-airmax.us.com/ five http://www.valentino-shoesoutlet.us/ major http://www.levisjeans.com.co/ pastoral http://www.michael-kors.com.es/ areas, http://www.michaelkors.so/ yak http://www.rayban-pascher.fr/ herders http://www.co-aol.com/ domesticated http://www.newbalance-outlet.org/ sheep http://www.celine-bags.org/ and http://www.weddingdressesuk.org.uk/ wild http://jets.nfljersey.us.com/ Tibetan http://www.converse-shoes.net/ antelope, http://www.insanity-workout.us.com/ wild http://www.chi-flatiron.us.com/ yak, http://redskins.nfljersey.us.com/ Tibetan http://www.newbalance.com.es/ wild http://www.cheapshoes.com.co/ ass, http://www.air-max.com.de/ Tibetan http://www.newbalancecanada.ca/ gazelle http://hawks.nbajersey.us.com/ and http://www.christianlouboutin-shoes.ca/ other http://www.pandorajewelry.top/ animals, http://www.maccosmetics.gr.com/ as http://www.marc-jacobs.us.com/ well http://www.uggsaustralia.com.co/ as http://www.ferragamoshoes.in.net/ black-necked http://www.tiffany-jewelry.net/ cranes, http://www.oakleyoutlet.it/ Tibetan http://www.michaelkors.co.nl/ frozen http://www.toms-outlets.us.com/ chickens http://www.giuseppe-zanotti.net/ and http://www.jimmy-choos.com/ other http://www.pradahandbags.net.co/ birds http://www.tommy-hilfiger-online-shop.de/ in http://www.kate-spadeoutlet.net/ harmony. http://www.mcmhandbags.com.co/ Northern http://www.christianlouboutinshoes.jp.net/ Tibet http://www.kate-spade.in.net/ is http://www.michael-kors-outlet-online.us.org/ a http://www.abercrombie-fitchs.cc/ jewel http://www.swarovski-canada.ca/ in http://www.barbour-factory.com/ the http://bills.nfljersey.us.com/ hearts http://www.michael-korsoutlet.cc/ of http://clippers.nbajersey.us.com/ the http://www.burberryoutlet-sale.in.net/ Tibetan http://northfaceoutlet.co-om.com/ people http://www.ralphlaurenoutlet-online.in.net/ have http://www.nikeairmaxins.co.uk/ a http://www.tommy-hilfiger.co.nl/ special http://www.jordanretro.org/ importance.

http://www.nike-air-max.com.se/ http://www.polooutlets-store.com/ http://www.nike-shoesoutlet.us/ http://www.prada.com.de/ http://www.ralphlauren-outlet.ca/ http://www.oakley-glassesoutlet.com/ http://www.nike-air-force.de/ http://www.longchamp-handbagsoutlet.us.com/ http://www.vans-schuhe.com.de/ http://nuggets.nbajersey.us.com/ http://www.ugg-boots.ca/ http://www.tiffanyand-co.net.co/ http://steelers.nfljersey.us.com/ http://www.tommyhilfiger-outlet.com/ http://www.michaelkorsoutletonline.net.co/ http://www.eyeglass-outlet.com/ http://panthers.nfljersey.us.com/ http://www.cheapjerseys.us.org/ http://uggboots.misblackfriday.com/ http://airmax.shoesoutlet.cc/ http://www.edhardy.us.org/ http://www.swarovskis.co.uk/ http://76ers.nbajersey.us.com/ http://www.tommy-hilfiger.com.de/ http://www.oakley-sunglassessale.us.com/ http://www.oakleysoutletonline.cc/ http://www.longchamps.us.com/ http://www.nike-freeruns.org.uk/ http://www.abercrombie-kid.us.com/ http://www.rolex-watches.us.com/ http://www.rolexwatchesforsale.us.com/ http://www.montres-pascher.fr/ http://rams.nfljersey.us.com/ http://chargers.nfljersey.us.com/ http://www.longchamphandbagsoutlet.net/ http://www.montblanc-penssale.com/ http://www.rayban-wayfarers.com/ http://www.newbalance-shoes.org/ http://pacers.nbajersey.us.com/ http://www.timberlands-paschere.fr/ http://heat.nbajersey.us.com/ http://www.airhuarache.co.uk/ http://www.toryburchsale.com.co/ http://www.christian-louboutinshoes.com.co/ http://www.nikeshoesoutlet.org.uk/ http://www.michaelkors-uk.org.uk/ http://www.burberry-outletstore.net/ http://www.outlet-burberry.net.co/ http://www.nike-outlet.us.com/ http://www.pumashoes.in.net/ http://www.weddingdresses-sale.com/ http://www.oakley.org.es/ http://www.hollisterclothes.us.com/ http://www.the-northfacejackets.us.com/ http://www.ray-bans.us.org/ http://www.tory-burchshoesoutlet.net/ http://www.prada-handbags.com.co/ http://www.iphone-cases.net.co/ http://falcons.nfljersey.us.com/ http://raptors.nbajersey.us.com/ http://www.barbour-jacketsoutlet.com/ http://www.hermesbags.jp.net/ http://www.cheap-raybanoutlet.com/ http://www.nike-roshe-run.de/ http://www.coachoutletstore.net.co/ http://warriors.nbajersey.us.com/ http://www.ralph-laurens.org.uk/ http://www.raybans-outlet.co.uk/ http://www.babyliss-pro.us.com/ http://www.nike-shoescanada.ca/ http://www.coach-factoryyoutletonline.net/ http://www.coco-chanel.com.de/ http://www.nikefree-run.org.uk/ http://www.mk-com.com/ http://www.katespadeoutlet.gb.net/ http://ravens.nfljersey.us.com/ http://jaguars.nfljersey.us.com/ http://www.michael-kors-taschen.com.de/ http://jazz.nbajersey.us.com/ http://texans.nfljersey.us.com/ http://www.michael-korsbags.co.uk/ http://www.air-huarache.co.uk/ http://www.gucci-outletsale.net/ http://www.burberryhandbagsoutlet.com/ http://www.ugg-australia.com.de/ http://www.ralphlaurenpolos.in.net/ http://www.designerhandbagsoutlet.net.co/ http://www.oakleysunglasses-canada.ca/ http://www.mizuno-running.net/ http://www.adidasshoes.top/ http://www.ghdshairstraightener.org.uk/ http://www.gucci-taschen-outlet.de/ http://www.instylers.us.com/ http://www.ghds-hairstraightener.com/ http://www.vans-shoes.net/ http://www.nikeair-max.ca/ http://www.canada-goosesjackets.us.com/ http://www.nikeskoes.dk/ http://www.bcbg-dresses.com/ http://www.nfl-jersey.us.com/ http://www.rayban-pas-cher.fr/ http://wizards.nbajersey.us.com/ http://www.coach-outletonline.ca/ http://www.adidas.com.se/ http://dolphins.nfljersey.us.com/ http://www.polos-ralphlauren.us.com/ http://azcardinals.nfljersey.us.com/ http://www.toryburch-sandals.in.net/ http://www.oakleyoutlet.ar.com/ http://www.tommyhilfigeroutlet.in.net/ http://www.reebok.com.de/ http://www.cheapjerseys.com.co/ http://www.airyeezy.us.com/ http://www.cheapthomassabos.co.uk/ http://bulls.nbajersey.us.com/ http://www.replica-watches.com.co/ http://www.tiffanyand-co.us/ http://www.michaelkorsbags.us.org/ http://www.mcmbags.us.com/ http://www.marc-jacobsonsale.com/ http://www.prada-shoes.com.co/ http://www.nikefree5.net/ http://lakers.nbajersey.us.com/ http://www.ugg-boots.us.org/ http://lions.nfljersey.us.com/ http://www.thenorthfacejackets.net.co/ http://www.pandora.com.de/ http://www.cheaprayban.com.co/ http://www.jimmy-chooshoes.com/ http://www.thenorth-face.ca/ http://www.pandoracharms-canada.ca/ http://www.toms-shoesoutlet.us/ http://www.beatsbydre.com.co/ http://www.coach-outletonline.net.co/ http://coachoutlet.euro-us.net/ http://www.rayban.org.es/ http://www.thenorthface.com.de/ http://www.thejoreseproject.com/ http://www.pulseras-pandora.com.es/ http://www.guccishoes-uk.org.uk/ http://www.nbajersey.us.com/ http://www.cheapuggboots.us.com/ http://www.nike-tnrequinpascher.fr/ http://www.nike.org.es/ http://www.toms--outlet.com.co/ http://www.uggboots.net.co/ http://www.cheap-nike-shoes.net/ http://www.cheapmichaelkors.us.org/ http://www.iphone-cases.cc/ http://www.truereligionjeans.net.co/

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • No HTML tags allowed
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.