Congress Should Require an Exit Strategy from Afghanistan

In March, President Obama told CBS' "60 Minutes" that the United States must have an "exit strategy" in Afghanistan.

Ninety Members of Congress agree. They're supporting H.R. 2404, a bill introduced by Representative Jim McGovern (D-MA) whose text is one sentence long: "Not later than December 31, 2009, the Secretary of Defense shall submit to Congress a report outlining the United States exit strategy for United States military forces in Afghanistan participating in Operation Enduring Freedom."

This week, Rep. McGovern is expected to try to attach this language to the 2010 military authorization bill. You can ask your Representative to support this effort here.

The Members of Congress are going a bit further than President Obama. They're saying not only that the U.S. should have an exit strategy, but that Congress and the American people should be told what it is.

It's Congress - and the American people - who have the power of the purse. This week, over the protests of progressive Democrats, Congress approved another war supplemental - paying for military escalation with no exit strategy - bringing the total spending for the war in Afghanistan to $223 billion since 2001, according to the Congressional Research Service.

Americans aren't just paying for the war through their tax dollars. More than 700 American soldiers have been killed in Afghanistan since 2001. Some 56,000 U.S. soldiers are in Afghanistan now, and President Obama has ordered 21,000 more soldiers to be sent there. Lt. Gen. Stanley McChrystal, the new U.S. commander in Afghanistan, has acknowledged to Congress that U.S. casualties will likely rise.

Afghan civilians are also paying a huge price for this war. A "mini-documentary" from Brave New Films shows the consequences of U.S. air strikes for Afghan civilians:

Earlier this year, an ABC poll reported that nearly four-fifths of Afghans say U.S. air strikes are unacceptable, while less than one in five wanted the U.S. to send more troops.

Critics of the escalating war in Afghanistan fear that we are being led into a quagmire like Vietnam. A January report from the Carnegie Foundation concluded that the presence of foreign forces in Afghanistan was likely the single most important factor driving the country's insurgencies. Already the Administration's announced escalation has had the effect of uniting different insurgent groups against the U.S.

We're told that we're supporting a democratic government in Afghanistan, but when that government asks us to stop deeply unpopular air strikes and Special Forces night raids, these protests are largely dismissed. When the Afghan government asks us to support meaningful negotiations with leaders of the country's insurgencies towards a political settlement of the country's conflicts, we don't even acknowledge the request. These are among the most important issues facing the country, and we don't allow the Afghan government to have effective say. We want the people of Afghanistan to see their government as legitimate - but when it comes to key issues that we control, we don't treat the government as legitimate, so it's little wonder if Afghans follow our lead in not taking their government seriously.

When Congress tried to impose a timetable for the withdrawal of U.S. forces from Iraq through legislation, we were told "arbitrary withdrawal timetables" were unacceptable. But eventually - also under pressure from the Iraqi government - the Bush Administration agreed to a withdrawal timetable. President Obama has repeatedly re-affirmed this timetable, including in his recent speech in Cairo.

In McGovern's bill, eighty-eight Members of Congress aren't demanding a timetable for withdrawal from Afghanistan. They're simply asking to be told what the plan is for getting to the situation where there is no U.S. military occupation of Afghanistan. In announcing his new strategy and in his speech in Cairo, President Obama said that the U.S. does not want to remain in Afghanistan indefinitely. But he hasn't told us what his plan is for doing something else.

One thing you almost never hear our leaders talk about is: how long are we going to be in Afghanistan? It's a forbidden topic. But occasionally something slips through: last year a British commander said the goal for handing back Kandahar air base was the year 2020.

If our government's exit strategy for Afghanistan includes 11 more years of war, don't the American people have a right to know that? If you think we do, urge your Member of Congress to support the McGovern bill.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I truly appreciate your efforts and I am waiting for your next write ups thanks once again.


I really enjoyed reading your article. I found this as an informative and interesting post, so i
think it is very useful and knowledgeable. I would like to thank you for the effort you have made in writing this article.

coach outletcoach outlet store onlinejames harden shoes 2015kate spade outletkate spade bagshttp://www.katespadecheap.netkatespade crossbodyhttp://www.katespade-diaperbag.netkate spade kate spade factory outletkate spade purseskate spade new yorkkate spade 2015kate spade handbagskate spade salekate spade ukkate spade surprise salekate spade totekate spade uk outlethttp://www.katespade-usa.orgLouis Vuittonhttp://www.louisvuitton-christmas.comhttp://www.louisvuittonclutchs.comLouis Vuitton Bagscheap louis vuitton bagsLV PursesLouis Vuitton Handbags outletLouis Vuitton outletlouis vuitton saleLouis Vuitton Outlet Onlinehttp://www.louisvuittonoutletyears.comlouis vuitton handbagslouis vuitton outletlouis vuitton storesLouis Vuitton Outlet onlineLouis Vuitton Sunglassesmichael kors jet set totemichael kors outletmichael kors handbagshttp://www.michaelkorsmkoutlet.orghttp://www.michaelkorsmksale.comhttp://www.michaelkorsmkwallet.commichael kors outlet online salemicheal kors outletmk outletmk bags outletmichael kors factory outletmk handbags outletmichael kors pursesmichael kors ukmk outlet onlinenike air huarachesnike air jordan shoes storehttp://www.nikeairmax1essential.comnike air maxnike Air MaxNike Air Maxhttp://www.nikeairmaxshoes-store.comnike air max thea menshttp://www.nikeairmaxtheapremium.comair max zeronike 3.0 flyknitnike free flyknit 4.0nike free run 5.0free trainer 5.0nike huarache blacknike huarache whitenike huarache womenNike Shoes On SaleNike Outletblack roshe runnike roshe flyknitnike roshe mennike roshe womennike zoom shoesnike zoom run the onehttp://www.rosherunblack.netroshe run flyknithttp://www.rosherunmen.orgwomen roshe runrosheshttp://www.usalouisvuittonoutlet-store.comLouis Vuitton Outlet Stores23 is back23 is back release dateair max 90 hyperfuse blacknike air max 90 hyperfusehttp://www.airmax90-ice.comnike air max 90 icehttp://www.airmax-zero.netnike air max zerocoach bags storehttp://www.coachfactory2015.comcoach outlet onlinecoach handbagscoach outlet online storecoach handbags outlethttp://www.coachpurses2015.comhttp://www.curryoneshoes.orgcurry 12015 james harden shoescheap james harden shoeshttp://www.kobe10sneaker.comkyrie irving 1 shoelebron 12 shoesmichael kors bagshttp://www.michaelkorshandbags2015.orghttp://www.2015michaelkorsoutlet.orgmichael kors onlinemichael kors purses storehttp://www.mkpurses2015.comcheap nike air max 90nike air max thea womenair max zero saleair max zero mens kyrie 1nike run the one for salehttp://www.nikeruntheone.comroshes for saleroshes shoeshttp://www.coachoutlet2015.nethttp://www.coachoutletstoreonline2015.comnike flyknit racer blackflyknit racer oreonike lunar flyknit 3flyknit lunar 3nike flyknit lunar 1nike janoskinike stefan janoski maxnike janoski maxhttp://www.nikeflyknitracer.orgnike flyknit racer for salehttp://www.stefanjanoskimax.netjanoski max blackstefan janoski shoeshttp://www.flyknitlunar2.comhttp://www.nikeflyknitlunar2.comnike flyknit lunar 2http://www.michaelkorsoutletmk.ccmichael kors outlet storehttp://www.michaelkorsoutletsonline.ccmichael kors bags on salemichael kors salemichael kors handbags outletmichael kors outlet ukhttp://www.michaelkors-outletstore.xyzcheap michael kors bagshttp://www.michaelkorsoutlet.winmichael kors online outlethttp://www.michaelkorsoutletonline.winhttp://www.michaelkorsbags.datemichael kors bags ukmichael kors online outletmichael kors bags outlethttp://www.michaelkorsbags.reviewhttp://www.michaelkorsoutlet.reviewhttp://www.michaelkorsoutletstore.reviewhttp://www.michaelkorsoutletonline.reviewmoncler outlet onlinehttp://www.mensmoncleroutlet.commoncler outlet ukmoncler outlet online shopmoncler outlet salemoncler jackets salemoncler on salehttp://www.monclerjacket-onlineshop.netmoncler online storemoncler jackets storeshttp://www.monclerjackets-stores.netmoncler outlet storehttp://www.monclerjacketsforwomens.nethttp://www.monclerjacketswomens.orgmoncler jackets for womenmoncler womens jacketscheap moncler coatsmoncler outlet storesmoncler jackets outletmoncler for salehttp://www.uggs-forwomen.netmen ugg bootsugg boot saleugg boots for womenugg australiauggs outlet storeugg australia saleuggs on saleugg boots on saleugg boots saleugg boots australiaugg boots outlet storecoach bags outlethttp://www.2015coachfactoryoutlet.comcoach factory outletcoach pursesmichael kors outlet storeshttp://www.2015michaelkorsoutlet.netAir JordanNike Air Jordan 4http://www.airjordan5forsale.comcheap air max zerocheap air jordan shoesCheap Louis Vuitton Bagshttp://www.cheaplouisvuitton-bagso.netLV handbagshttp://www.cheapnikeairmaxltd.comcoach 80% off handbagscoach bags on salehttp://www.coachbagsoutletfactory.netcoach bags ukcoach promo codescoach bags usacoach couponscoach factory store coach outlet store onlinecoach outlet promo code

Love it! Very interesting topics, I hope the incoming comments and suggestion are equally positive. Thank you for sharing this information that is actually helpful.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • No HTML tags allowed
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.