Honduran Coup Decree Shows Coup "Justification" Was After the Fact

Supporters in the U.S. of the coup in Honduras have frequently made two claims to justify it which are demonstrably false, which have nonetheless been widely accepted in the U.S., because they have been largely unchallenged in the U.S. media: the Honduran Congress authorized Zelaya's removal, and the basis for that removal was Article 239 of the Honduran Constitution, which forbids someone from being President if he has already been President, and says that anyone who advocates changing this provision will cease to be President.

The actual decree of the Honduran Congress is attached. Note the following.

1) the document never mentions Article 239.

2) the document is dated "MIERCOLES 1 DE JULIO DEL 2009," i.e. Wednesday, July 1, 2009, three days after the coup on Sunday, June 28.

So: 1) the decree of the Honduran Congress, which is being cited as justification for it, was produced when the coup was already three days old, and 2) this decree never mentioned Article 239.

Note that President Zelaya didn't advocate any change to term limits. He proposed a nonbinding referendum on whether there should be a constitutional convention. Even had the nonbinding referendum been successful, there is no plausible scenario in which it would have led to a change in this provision of the constitution prior to the scheduled November election in which Zelaya was to be replaced and in which he was not a candidate. At most it would have resulted in a binding referendum for a constitutional referendum on the same November ballot on which Zelaya would have been replaced. So the claim that President Zelaya was "trying to extend his term" is not only false, but logically impossible.

As much as I support Zelaya and desire the golpista's demise, I must point out that the date you give: MIERCOLES 1 DE JULIO DEL 2009, is the publication date of the "Gaceta" in which the decree was published.

At the very end of the decree is the date of its submission:

"Dado en la ciudad de Tegucigalpa, municipal del Distrito Central, en el Salón de Sesiones del Congresso Nacional, a los veintiocho dias del mes de junio del año mil nueve."

That translates (roughly) as:

“Given in the city of Tegucigalpa, …of the Central District, in the Assembly hall the of the National Congress, [on] the twenty-eight[h] day of the month of June of year thousands nine.”

One can question whether or not the decree is a back-dated forgery (not unlikely) but saying that the dateline of publication is the actual date of the event is misleading. It's akin to saying the dateline of a story in the NYT reporting a congressional vote three days earlier is the actual day of the vote.

Further, once the misleading statement is 'outed' it tends to discredit anything further from the authors.

You must do better!

chentingting11/9
http://www.monclerjackets-onlinestore.commoncler jackets storeshttp://www.monclerjackets-stores.netmoncler outlet storemoncler jackets for menshttp://www.monclerjacketswomens.orgmoncler jackets womensmoncler jackets outletcheap moncler coatsmoncler 2015moncler outlet usamoncler saleshttp://www.uggs-forwomen.netblack ugg bootsmen ugg bootshttp://www.uggboots-forwomen.orguggs salehttp://www.saleuggbootsoutletstore.nethttp://www.saleuggsoutletstore.orguggs on salehttp://www.womenuggbootssale.netugg boots saleuggs for menhttp://www.michaelkorsoutletonline.wincoach bagscoach outletcoach factory outlet onlinecoach purses outletmichael kors bagshttp://www.2015michaelkorsoutlet.netAir Jordan 11 Release DateAir Jordan 4 Retrohttp://www.airjordan5forsale.comcheap air max zerocheap air jordan shoesCheap Louis Vuitton BagsLouis Vuitton Outlethttp://www.cheaplvbags-top.netnike air maxcoach outlet 80% offhttp://www.coachbags-onsale.netcoach outlet factoryhttp://www.coachbagssaleuk.comcoach outlet promo codehttp://www.coachfactoryusa.netcoach outlet onlinehttp://www.coachoutlet-factorystore.orgcoach outlet storehttp://www.coachoutletpromocode.comcoach outlet storecoach outlet store onlinejames harden shoeskate spade handbags outletkate spade outletkate spade usakate spade bag outletkate spade oninekate spade factorykate spade purseskate spade new yorkkate spade 2015kate spade outlet onlinekate spade salekate spade ukhttp://www.katespadesurprisesale.comkate spade totehttp://www.katespadeukoutlet.comhttp://www.katespade-usa.orglouis vuitton handbagsLouis Vuitton pursesLouis Vuitton clutch baghttp://www.louisvuitton-lv.us.comlouis vuitton luggagelouis vuitton walletsnew Louis VuittonLouis Vuitton outletlouis vuitton saleLouis Vuitton StoreLouis Vuitton Bagshttp://www.louisvuitton-plazabags.comlouis vuitton storelouis vuitton store 2015Louis Vuitton Sunglasseslouis vuitton outletmichael kors jet set walletmichael kors outlet onlinemk bagsmk outlet onlinehttp://www.michaelkorsmksale.commichael kors handbagshttp://www.michaelkorsoutletonlinee.netmicheal kors outlet storemichael kors factory storehttp://www.mkmichaelkorsbags.netmk factory outlethttp://www.mkmichaelkorshandbags.nethttp://www.mkmichaelkorspurses.commichael kors ukhttp://www.mk-outletonline.orgnike huarachesauthentic nike air jordan shoeshttp://www.nikeairmax1essential.comnike air max 1 nike Air MaxNike Air Max 90 Shoesair max shoesnike air max thea menshttp://www.nikeairmaxtheapremium.comair max zero salenike free 3.0 flyknitnike 4.0 flyknitnike free run 5.0nike free trainernike air huarache blackwhite huaracheswomens nike huaracheNike Shoes On SaleNike LunarGlipseblack roshe runnike roshe run flyknitnike roshe run mennike roshe run womennike zoom run the onenike run the one for saleroshe run blackroshe flyknithttp://www.rosherunmen.orgnike roshe womenrosheshttp://www.usalouisvuittonoutlet-store.comLouis Vuitton Outlet Stores23isback release23 is back 2015 release datesair max 90 hyperfuse rednike air max 90 hyperfuseair max 90 icenike air max 90 icehttp://www.airmax-zero.netair max zero menscoach bags onlinecoach factory storehttp://www.coachfactoryoutletonline2015.comhttp://www.coachhandbags2015.orghttp://www.coachoutletonlineny.netcoach handbags outletcoach purses onlinecurry onehttp://www.curryoneshoes.nethttp://www.jameshardensneaker.orgnew james harden shoeskobe 10 elitekyrie 1 shoeslebrons shoesmichael kors online storemichael kors handbags outletmichael kors outlet storehttp://www.michaelkorsoutletonline2015.orghttp://www.michaelkorspurses2015.nethttp://www.mkpurses2015.comcheap air max 90nike air max thea womenair max zero 2015air max zero womenhttp://www.nike-kyrie1.netnike kyrie 1nike zoom shoesjames harden for saleroshes for salehttp://www.roshesshes.netcoach bags outlethttp://www.coachoutletstoreonline2015.comflyknit racer for saleflyknit racer oreoflyknit lunar 3nike flyknit lunar 3nike flyknit lunar 2http://www.nikejanoski.nethttp://www.janoskimax.netnike janoski maxnike flyknit racer for salenike flyknit racer oreonike waffle racerstefan janoski maxnike stefan janoskihttp://www.flyknitlunar2.comnike flyknit lunar2http://www.nikeflyknitlunar1.commichael kors online outlethttp://www.2015michaelkorsoutletstores.cchttp://www.michaelkorsoutletsonline.cccheap michael kors bagsmichael kors crossbody baghttp://www.michaelkors-outlet.xyzmichael kors outlet ukhttp://www.michaelkors-outletstore.xyzhttp://www.michaelkorsbags.winmichael kors bags on salehttp://www.michaelkorsoutletstore.winmichael kors salecheap michael kors handbagsmichael kors bags ukmichael kors factory outletmichael kors usahttp://www.michaelkorsbags.reviewmichael kors onlinemichael kors walletsmichael kors storemoncler jackets mensmoncler outlet onlinemoncler sale outlethttp://www.moncler-outletonlines.netmoncler outlet storesmoncler jackets on salecheap moncler jacketshttp://www.monclerjacket-onlineshop.net

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • No HTML tags allowed
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.