On Afghan Election, Panetta is Simply Stating the Obvious

Live long enough, and you get to have diverse experiences. Today I get to defend the head of the CIA for telling the truth.

CIA director Leon Panetta is catching some flak on the Intertubes for telling Voice of America that

even if suspect ballots are discounted, President Hamid Karzai will in all likelihood win re-election.

But if you look at the numbers for 15 seconds, it's clear that Panetta is simply stating the obvious.

Panetta's full quote was:

"It's clear that there was some degree of corruption and fraud involved in the election," Panetta said. "It's being viewed now by the commissions involved in counting those votes. I think what appears to be the case is that even after they eliminate some of the votes that resulted because of fraud, that Karzai will still - still looks like the individual who's going to be able to win that election."

Here are the numbers, according to the New York Times on September 16:

Current tally:

Karzai 3,093,256 54.6%
Abdullah 1,571,581 27.8%
Valid votes 5,662,758

Ballots being reviewed:

Karzai 1,100,000
Abdullah 300,000

So, if every ballot being reviewed were thrown out, the result would be:

With all reviewed ballots excluded:
Karzai 1,993,256 46.8%
Abdullah 1,271,581 29.8%
Valid 4,262,758

But if half of the reviewed ballots were thrown out (assuming that half of reviewed Karzai ballots and half of reviewed Abdullah ballots are thrown out - that is, throwing out more than 3 times as many Karzai ballots as Abdullah ballots), the result would be

With half of reviewed ballots excluded:
Karzai 2,543,256 51.2%
Abdullah 1,421,581 28.6%
Valid 4,962,758

That is, if half of the reviewed ballots are thrown out, Karzai still has a first round victory. This suggests that Panetta's statement that, "even after they eliminate some of the votes that resulted because of fraud" it looks like Karzai will win, is probably correct.

Note that, contrary to what some people seem to believe, Abdullah's people also stole votes, as the Washington Post reported on August 28. So it's quite reasonable to expect that if many of Karzai's reviewed votes are excluded, a proportionate number of Abdullah's reviewed votes will also be excluded.

Assuming again an equal rate of excluding votes among those now attached to either camp, the crossover point is 66%: roughly speaking, to deny Karzai a first round victory, two-thirds of the votes under review have to be thrown out.

The overall result should not be very surprising to anyone who read the Washington Post on August 11. The Post reported:

In a poll released Monday, Karzai led with 45 percent of the vote among decided voters, compared with 25 percent for Abdullah Abdullah, a former foreign minister. The U.S.-government-funded poll by Glevum Associates, conducted July 8-19, had Ghani fourth, with 4 percent of the vote.

So, any of the above results are not far away from what a U.S.-government-poll predicted.

new jersey car insurance 866855 buy viagra dbu cheap auto insurance >:-( florida auto insurance 570 cheap car insurance vsrlb cheap auto insurance 866

buy viagra in usa vgge buy viagra %[[ a auto insurance uuyfp purchase cialis on the internet 717502 online college dkwlqh new york car insurance :-PPP buying viagra >:P

prednisone unre sildenafil vardenafil and tadalafil 631 auto insurance quotes IL =-)) online colleges :-))) online car insurance 739526 auto insurance quotes Cheyenne =OOO viagra vyb

taking cialis and viagra together mrr buy viagra zqjesu discount auto insurance brthaz purchase cialis 50273 cialis yeg cheap car insurance 961419

prednisone unre sildenafil vardenafil and tadalafil 631 auto insurance quotes IL =-)) online colleges :-))) online car insurance 739526 auto insurance quotes Cheyenne =OOO viagra vyb

accredited online colleges >:PPP low car insurance 540 online auto insurance 2903 cialis online xxsu car insurance zysquw levitra 4474 generic cialis online =-]]]

accutane tgo online auto insurance ryelop Memphis car insurance quotes :-PPP cialis =))) viagra online 129373 eastwood auto insurance :D

prednisone no prescription :OO average car insurance rates new york :[ auto insurance quotes >:)) affordable car insurance 096 cialis viagra ptjocd

Buy Discount Car Insurance Online =O accutane %) auto insurance quotes Nebraska 179404 car insurance quotes OK khmiol Vermont cheap car insurance 278662 prednisone 005 online auto insurance quotes 7714

South Dakota cheap car insurance 753827 levitra buy ydklng fl car indurance 6088 state auto insurance 48084 insurance auto auctions :-OOO pregressive insurance 8P

auto insurance quotes florida %( Best prices on Cialis or Viagra loqd cialis qswlne florida car insurance upb car insurance quotes qyn cialis free viagra 8-D

Hi! ALL buy viagra viagra online viagra samples viagra cheap viagra cheap viagra viagra viagra sale buy viagra buy viagra,cialis online,generic cialis,cialis,buy cialis,cialis,buy cialis,cialis,cialis online,cheap cialis,cialis professional rtybtybtybu64

where to buy cialifill ntc cars insurance quotes hsz car insurance quotes =-OO VIAGRA REORDER bdc cheap ceilies vabbtp buy pfizer viagra online 697 auto insurance auto 103141

car insurance in florida Phoenix :OO free quotes auto insurance 8]]] auto insurance quotes Birmingham zdyqk auto insurance %]]] car insurance sample ala accutane side effects swollen lips %)

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • No HTML tags allowed
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.