"Lessons in Disaster": If Obama Caves to the Pentagon, He's No Jack Kennedy

President Obama knows better than to agree to General McChrystal's proposal for military escalation in Afghanistan. He read the book.

On October 7, the Wall Street Journal reported that top officials of the Obama Administration, including President Obama himself, had recently read Gordon Goldstein's book on the path to U.S. military escalation in Vietnam: Lessons in Disaster: McGeorge Bundy and the Path to War in Vietnam.

The Journal reported that "For opponents of a major troop increase, led by Biden and Emanuel, "'Lessons in Disaster' ... encapsulates their concerns about accepting military advice unchallenged."

Indeed, a central theme of the book is President Kennedy's willingness, on the question of ground troops in Vietnam, to do what President Obama has not yet done regarding demands for military escalation in Afghanistan: stand up to the U.S. military and say no.

Journalist Seymour Hersh, a close student of the U.S. military since he broke the story of the My Lai massacre, says the U.S. army is "in a war against the White House - and they feel they have Obama boxed in." Hersh says the only way out is for Obama to stand up to the Pentagon. "He's either going to let the Pentagon run him or he has to run the Pentagon," Hersh said. If he doesn't, "this stuff is going to be the ruin of his presidency." The only way for the U.S. to extricate itself from the conflict, Hersh says, is to negotiate with the Taliban. "It's the only way out," he said. "I know that there's a lot of discussion in the White House about this now. But Obama is going to have to take charge, and there's no evidence he's going to do that."

There's a conventional wisdom now that Obama simply can't "take charge," because it's politically impossible. According to this view, McChrystal's request sets up the Republicans to blame Obama for "losing Afghanistan" if he doesn't agree to McChrystal's request - (even though, as Fareed Zakaria notes in the Washington Post, over the past 18 months, troop levels in Afghanistan have almost tripled.)

But Goldstein's book strongly argues that President Obama could say no to the U.S. military. The perceived threat to the U.S. from "international Communism" was at least as powerful a bogey in American politics in 1961 as the threat of international terrorism is today.

Goldstein notes (p. 30) that "in the fall of 1961, Kennedy's most senior advisers almost unanimously warned him that the odds were sharply against avoiding a catastrophic defeat in Vietnam unless the president approved the first increment of a ground combat force deployment that might ultimately reach six divisions, or more than 200,000 men." Yet Kennedy rejected every proposal to send combat troops to Vietnam.

Kennedy also rejected U.S. military demands for U.S. military intervention in Laos (p. 46-47.) In April 1961, Admiral Arleigh Burke, chief of naval operations, argued "strongly and repeatedly" that without U.S. military intervention in Laos, "all Southeast Asia will be lost." The majority of Kennedy's advisers supported the deployment of combat troops to South Vietnam, Thailand, and government-controlled positions in Laos. If that failed to produce a cease-fire, Kennedy was advised to use tactical nuclear weapons against Laotian guerrillas. If China or North Vietnam intervened, those countries should be bombed and, if necessary, attacked with nuclear weapons.

Instead of taking any of this advice, Kennedy pressed for a diplomatic solution, bringing about a cease-fire and eventually an agreement for the neutralization of Laos.

Kennedy's willingness to stand up to military and civilian advisers who seemed to automatically advocate the most militarily aggressive U.S. response to any situation was informed by the debacle of the Bay of Pigs invasion, when Kennedy was badly burned by bad advice - not just advice that was bad in the sense of being wrong in its predictions, but advice that was deceitful - bad in the sense of "bad faith" and withholding key information. The same advisers who demanded U.S. military intervention in Laos had advised Kennedy to approve the Bay of Pigs operation - the invasion of Cuba by U.S.-supported Cuban exiles. Before the invasion, Kennedy's advisers talked up the great prospects for success. In approving it, Kennedy made clear that if it failed, he would not authorize direct U.S. military intervention to save it. When - predictably - the operation failed, Kennedy's advisers demanded direct U.S. military intervention to save it. In fact, the documentary record shows that the CIA knew the operation would fail without direct U.S. military intervention, but withheld this information from Kennedy, and that their plan all along was to box Kennedy into a situation where he would be compelled to involve U.S. forces. By Kennedy's own account, the CIA and the military didn't believe that a "new president" would stand up to them. (p.40)

When you read this history, you see Vice-President Biden's prediction that President Obama would be "tested" in a new light. Yes, President Obama is being tested - but not by foreign adversaries. President Obama is being tested by the Pentagon.

President Kennedy was no dove. Kennedy was willing to violate international law and Kennedy was willing to authorize the killing of people in foreign countries who had committed no crime against the people of the United States. What Kennedy was not willing to do was commit U.S. ground troops to an unwinnable war in Vietnam. And he wasn't willing to commit U.S. ground troops - as some of his advisers were - in the belief that protecting U.S. "credibility" meant that it would be better to fight and lose than not to fight. You don't have to be a dove to understand what President Kennedy understood: putting U.S. troops on the ground somewhere doesn't automatically make you more powerful. Indeed, it could make you less powerful, because, all other things being equal, a person with more options is more powerful than a person with fewer options. And if military escalation closes off opportunities for diplomatic and political solutions, it makes you less powerful.

Some people at the top of the Obama Administration clearly get this. Indeed, the Journal reported that "Administration officials in the Biden camp fear they too could close off the path to a more peaceful resolution of the conflict if 40,000 more troops are sent."

This is the key danger in approving McChrystal's request. Of course, in the short run, sending more troops almost surely means that more U.S. troops will die and more Afghan civilians will die, and that would be bad enough. But the even greater danger is that it might make the eventual, inevitable political resolution of the conflict more difficult, thereby prolonging it and causing many more needless deaths.

National Security Adviser McGeorge Bundy believed that after the U.S. escalated and "Americanized" the Vietnam war in 1965, a diplomatic solution was "not viable." Repeating this mistake - making a diplomatic resolution "not viable" - is the great danger in McChrystal's request. Bundy said later that Congress knew perfectly well what was at stake when President Johnson escalated U.S. involvement in 1965, and deliberately chose not to be involved. That observation is even more relevant today. No-one in Congress can claim ignorance of a debate that has been aired in the media much more than the 1965 escalation decision was. If Congress isn't speaking up, it must be that they're not hearing enough from their constituents.

As former Marine captain Matthew Hoh told the Washington Post following his letter of resignation as a top U.S. official in Afghanistan,

"I want people in Iowa, people in Arkansas, people in Arizona, to call their congressman and say, 'Listen, I don't think this is right.' "

Now there's a great American patriot. Do what he says.

Hi! ALL buy viagra viagra viagra discount viagra viagra cheap viagra generic viagra viagra viagra cheap viagra,generic cialis,cialis price,cialis online,buy cialis,cialis,buy cialis,cialis daily,buy cialis,cheap cialis,cialis rtybtybtybu64

[linlei0204] nike air jordan retro shoes ray ban sunglasses for cheap sale on ray ban aviators knockoff ray bans for sale womens nike dunk high air jordan 12 retro oakleysunglasses is the coach factory online real oakley headquarters coach factory site oakley backpack free oakley sunglasses for military nice ray ban sunglasses coach wholesale nike air max 1 ray ban official nike breathe free best place to buy ray ban oakley wallet sale ray ban wayfarer ray bans sunglasses on sale oakley outlet store ray ban sunglass frames coach outlet printable coupons bag coach customize oakleys coach pocket books nike breathe free ii coach boots outlet green nike air max coaching and mentoring oakley scalpel sunglasses online coach outlet factory wayfarer ray bans sunglasses best place to buy ray bans ray ban goggles mens nike dunk low nike shox white ray ban sunglass lens replacement ray ban junior sunglasses mens oakley sunglasses oakley glasses cheap ray ban 4118 cheap coach handbags oakley monster dog oakley sale sunglasses nike air jordan xi retro discount ray bans outlet ray bans discount nike air jordan 13 retro oakley golf bags ray ban wayfarer 54mm coach outlets oakley jawbone parts ray bans glasses frames nike zoom waffle racer oakley replacement lens air jordan space jams where is the coach outlet store hijinx oakley coupons for coach outlet stores coach outlet free shipping cheap oakley baseball sunglasses coach hand bag air jordan 4 oakley grapevine oakley custom sunglasses ray ban size chart ray bans wayfarer eyeglasses ray bans knockoffs official ray ban outlets coach promotional code ray bans sunglasses wayfarer oakley ski gear oakley ballistic eyewear oakley behave shop coach outlet online cheap ray ban aviators oakley t shirts ray ban rb3269 ray ban 4159 coach clearance purses ray bans eyeglasses for women ray ban wayfarer black nike shox size 14 ray ban sunglasses prescription nike outlet dallas ray ban logo nike free runner 50 oakley lenses hijinx oakley sunglasses oakley eyewear womens ray ban aviators cheap sunglasses ray ban oakley oil rig sunglasses nike outlet portland oregon oakley m frame strike oakley sunglasses for cheap coach clearance outlet online ray ban wayfarer discount ray ban rb3025 aviator sunglasses oakley for sale ray ban frames outlet oakley repairs cheap ray ban eyewear oakley gloves styles of ray bans nike air jordan 8 coach factory outlet online store fake coach factory stores ray ban sunglasses shop online oakley golf shoes ray ban aviator sunglasses air jordan 11 for sale ray ban factory outlet usa coach outlet discount ray ban signet prescription oakley sunglasses online air jordan 8 retro oakley wayfarer oakley sunglasses for kids coach outlet lebanon tn ray ban classic aviator oakley jackets ray ban wayfarer white white oakleys nike zoom huarache coach outlet anthem oakley sunglasses cheap oakley jury coach bookbags women ray ban aviators coach on sale oakley shorts ray ban sunglasses guarantee all black ray ban wayfarer nike dunk pigeon oakley half jacket ray ban colors nike factory outlet orlando fake ray ban wayfarer sunglasses vintage coach bags coach for cheap oakley gascan sunglasses ray ban rb3026 nike outlet store portland coach online factory outlet latest ray ban sunglasses for women fake oakleys wholesale coach outlet online canada nike free 50 running shoe ray ban classic clubmaster oakley wholesale nike shox baseball cleats ray bans outlet store oakley whisker polarized coach keychain jordan air nike ray ban sunglass aviator ray ban wayfarer clear lens girls with ray bans ray ban caravans new wayfarer ray ban coach leather cleaner ray ban rb3016 coach outlet vacaville ray ban 4099 discount ray ban eyeglasses oakley hats oakley radar polarized oakley beckon coach outlet sawgrass ray ban clubmaster black ray ban wayfarer tortoise ray ban mens sunglasses sale coach bags factory outlet youth nike shox oakley sunglasses reviews coach handbags outlets oakley sunglasses gascan nike air max 2 coach outlet online factory sale ray ban 52mm aviator nike shox nz oakley transistor air jordan shoes discount ray bans and oakleys coach change purse oakley sunglasses sale coach outlet north bend nike dunk sea crystal city of oakley radar path oakley all black nike air max new nike air max oakley split thump ray ban rb8301 original ray ban sunglasses coach discount bags oakleys sunglasses

[linlei0319] castle rock coach outlet coach outlet grove city pa gilroy coach outlet coach handbags outlet sale coach wallets on sale coach factory outlet reviews coachoutlet real coach bags coerver coaching coach handbags outlet store coach outlet diaper bags albertville coach outlet coach wallet men coach bag outlet store las vegas coach outlet ontario mills coach outlet coach bags outlet sales coach outlet wallets for women coach outlet waikele coach factory outlets online sale accessory store outlet football coach personal coaching coach outlet black friday coach wallets outlet online coach outlet invitation only coach outlet store online free shipping coach discount pink coach purse coach sale handbags coach purse outlet online coach outlet jeffersonville coach store outlet online coach umbrella coach briefcase women coach outlet inventory coach outlet shopping coach wallets for women outlet coach book bags coach legacy coach shoes outlet store online coach duffle bag coach factory outlet wallets football coaching jobs red coach purse coach outlet factory store online authentic coach outlet store online coach factory outlet quality outlet coach handbags coach classic outlet classic coach bags coach bags outlet on sale coupons for coach outlet stores coach logo vocal coach coach vacaville outlet coach patchwork purse coach outlit coach online outlet sale coach tote bags coach outlet clearance online coach bags clearance soccer coach christian coaching coach messenger bags coach purses for sale coach outlet store's picture coach outlet online sale 2013 coach premium outlet coach outlet sale coach change purse nearest coach outlet store business coaches green coach purse coach outlet store website coach outlet in phoenix coach barrett sneaker coach outlet williamsburg new coach purses madison coach bag coach factory outlet sales coach products fake coach purses coach repair coach outlet kansas city san marcos coach outlet the coach outlet store wrentham coach outlet coach factory online outlet store coach outlet purse discontinued coach purses coach discount outlet coach cosmetic bag coach outlet houston tx accounting coach coach authentic outlet online coach factory invitation only online sale coach online coupons coach factory outlet online store sale coach factory outlet near me louis vuitton buy online louis vuitton san antonio louis vuitton outlet handbags louis vuitton ad louis vuitton purses cheap authentic louis vuitton wristlets louis vuitton totes why are louis vuitton bags expensive louis vuitton bags outlet store authentic louis vuitton resale pre owned louis vuitton louis vuitton outlet seattle pink louis vuitton bag louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton murakami black louis vuitton bag cheap louis vuitton wallet louis vuitton outlet locations where to buy louis vuitton bags louis vuitton totes outlet louis vuitton eyeglasses louis vuitton attitude sunglasses cheap authentic louis vuitton bags louis vuitton france where is a louis vuitton outlet store louis vuitton baby shoes louis vuitton handbags outlet online louis vuitton outlet store in usa louis vuitton idylle where is louis vuitton made louis vuitton wallet men louis vuitton pumps louis vuitton leather louis vuitton vintage louis vuitton outlet san diego louis vuitton online outlet authentic louis vuitton baby bag louis vuitton bags cheap louis vuitton louis vuitton online louis vuitton wallets for men louis vuitton handbags on sale usa cheap real louis vuitton louis vuitton totally mm louis vuitton mens jeans louis vuitton sale bags pre owned louis vuitton handbags louis vuitton speedy handbags louis vuitton key chain louis vuitton don louis vuitton tivoli louis vuitton keepall 55 louis vuitton men belt louis vuitton duffle bag for men louis vuitton mens shirts louis vuitton scottsdale shoes louis vuitton louis vuitton watches lv louis vuitton louis vuitton houston louis vuitton beach bag louis vuitton shirts for men louis vuitton shades louis vuitton consignment louis vuitton bag outlet online louis vuitton store online louis vuitton men shoes louis vuitton belt buckle authentic louis vuitton purse louis vuitton louis vuitton outlet fefffffflouis vuitton outlet cheap louis vuitton purses for sale authentic louis vuitton on sale louis vuitton denim bags reviews on louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton kids louis vuitton shoes sale louis vuitton handbags outlet sale where can i buy louis vuitton online does louis vuitton have an outlet online louis vuitton clothing for men louis vuitton jeans for men authentic louis vuitton outlet stores louis vuitton totally pm louis vuitton usa outlet louis vuitton crossbody bag louis vuitton official outlet louis vuitton shoes cheap cheap bags louis vuitton used authentic louis vuitton kanye west louis vuitton louis vuitton pochette louis vuitton luggage louis vuitton bloomsbury eva clutch louis vuitton louis vuitton loafers louis vuitton designer shoes louis vuitton tivoli pm louis vuitton for men where can i find louis vuitton handbags louis vuitton usa handbags michael kors austin michael kors mk5055 michael kor watch michael kors black shoes michael kors trench coat michael kors portland satchel michael kors at macy s michael kors uk michael kors boot watches for women michael kors michael kors store outlet michael kors glitz watch michael kors tote sale michael kors bags macy s authentic michael kors handbags outlet michael kors for men michael kors metallic handbag cheap authentic michael kors handbags michael kors sale handbags wholesale michael kors the official michael kors outlet michael kors outlet williamsburg michael kors kors website legit michael kors silver bag michael kors locations michael kors accessories what is michael kors michael kors ceramic white watch new michael kors jet set michael kors michael kors black watches michael kors mens wallet michael kors purse outlet michael kors grayson bag michael kors handbags outlet cheap michael by michael kors shoes michael kors coupons michael kors crossbody bag michael kors hand bags michael kors silicone watch best michael kors handbags michael kors handbag sale michael kors fulton flats men michael kors watch michael kors ballet flats michael kors kingsbury tote michael kors miami michael kors wrap watch michael kors leather michael kors totes michael kors watches at macy s michael kors handbags for cheap tortoise michael kors watch is there a michael kors outlet online michael kors snakeskin purse michael kors outlet vegas michael kors outlet handbags sale michael kors retailers discount michael kors outlet cheap michael kors watches for women michael kors men s watches michael kors handbags hamilton michael kors handbags discount michael kors ceramic watch michael kors heels michael kors handbags 2013 michael kors men watches on sale michael kors leather bags michael kors collection official michael kors factory outlet michael kors canada outlet michael kors 2013 handbags michael kors white watch macy michael kors handbags michael kors slippers michael kors necklace michael kors factory outlet website is michael kors outlet michael kors outlet online reviews michael kors careers michael kors dress plus size michael kors michael kors black friday michael kors outlet online scam find michael kors outlet michael kors prime outlet cheap michael kors watches outlet michael kors outlet cabazon red michael kors bag michael kors watches discount cheap handbags michael kors new michael kors watches michael kors hamilton large michael kors shirts for men michael kors hobo bag wholesale michael kors watches michael kors watches outlet store what is the official michael kors outlet site michael kors set buy michael kors

Air Maxhttp://www.nikeairmaxshoes-store.comnike air max thea womenshttp://www.nikeairmaxtheapremium.comair max zero salenike flyknit 3.0http://www.nikefree40flyknit.netnike free 5.0nike free 5.0 trainernike huarache triple blackwhite huarachesnike huarache womensNike Shoes On SaleNike Outlet Onlinenike roshe run all blacknike flyknit roshe runnike roshe menwomen roshe runnike zoom shoesnike zoom run the onehttp://www.rosherunblack.nethttp://www.rosherunflyknit.nethttp://www.rosherunmen.orgnike roshe womenroshes mensLouis Vuitton OutletLouis Vuitton Outlet Online23 is back23 is back 2015 release dateshttp://www.airmax90-hyperfuse.netair max 90 hyperfusenike air max 90http://www.airmax90-ice.orghttp://www.airmax-zero.netnike air max zerohttp://www.coachbags2015.nethttp://www.coachfactory2015.comhttp://www.coachfactoryoutletonline2015.comcoach handbags outletcoach outlet storehttp://www.coachoutletstore2015.orgcoach purses outletcurry onehttp://www.curryoneshoes.netjames harden shoesnew james harden shoeshttp://www.kobe10sneaker.comkyrie 1 usalebron james shoeshttp://www.michaelkorsbags2015.netmichael kors handbags onlinemichael kors outlet onlinehttp://www.michaelkorsoutletonline2015.orghttp://www.michaelkorspurses2015.netmk outletcheap air max 90nike air max thea menshttp://www.nike-airmaxzero.orgair max zero womennike kyrie 1kyrie irving 1 shoenike run the one for salejames harden for salehttp://www.roshesshoes.comnike roshescoach outlet onlinehttp://www.coachoutletstoreonline2015.comhttp://www.nikeflyknitracer.netnike flyknit racer for saleflyknit lunar 3http://www.flyknitlunar3.netnike flyknit lunar 2nike janoskinike janoski maxnike sb stefan janoski maxnike flyknit racer oreohttp://www.flyknitracer.orghttp://www.stefanjanoskimax.nethttp://www.stefanjanoskishoes.nethttp://www.nikeflyknitlunar3.orgnike lunar flyknit 3flyknit lunar 2http://www.nikeflyknitlunar1.comhttp://www.michaelkorsoutletmk.ccmichael kors online outletcheap michael korscheap michael kors bagsmichael kors salemichael kors outlet storemichael kors outlet ukmichael kors storemichael kors bags outletmichael kors bags on salehttp://www.michaelkorsoutletstore.winhttp://www.michaelkorsoutletonline.winhttp://www.michaelkorsbags.datehttp://www.michaelkorsoutlet.datemichael kors factory outlethttp://www.michaelkorsoutletonline.datemichael kors jet sethttp://www.michaelkorsoutlet.reviewmichael kors online outletmichael kors backpackmoncler outlet onlinemoncler outlet usamoncler sale outletmoncler outlet online shopmoncler outlet salemoncler jackets on salemoncler jackets cheaphttp://www.monclerjacket-onlineshop.nethttp://www.monclerjackets-onlinestore.commoncler online storehttp://www.monclerjackets-stores.netmoncler outlet storeshttp://www.monclerjacketsforwomens.netmoncler on salemoncler jackets womenshttp://www.monclerformens.netcheap moncler coatshttp://www.moncler-outletsale.orghttp://www.moncler-forsale.netmoncler jackets saleuggs for womenmen ugg bootshttp://www.uggboots-formen.netcheap ugg bootshttp://www.baileybutton-uggs.netuggs outlet storeugg australia saleuggs boots on saleugg boot saleugg boots saleuggs for menblack ugg bootscoach bagscoach factorycoach factory outlet onlinecheap coach pursesmichael kors outlet storesmichael kors outletnike Air Jordan 11Nike Air Jordan 4air jordan 5air max zero for salecheap air jordan shoes for saleLouis Vuitton bagshttp://www.cheaplouisvuitton-bagso.nethttp://www.cheaplvbags-top.netair max ltdcoach outlet 80% offhttp://www.coachbags-onsale.netcoach bags outletcoach bags on salecoach promo codeshttp://www.coachfactoryusa.nethttp://www.coach-outletcoupons.comhttp://www.coachoutlet-factorystore.orghttp://www.coachoutletnj.netcoach outlet promo codehttp://www.coachoutletstoreinc.orghttp://www.coachoutletstoreny.comjames harden shoes for salehttp://www.katespade2015.orgkate spade bagskate spade outletkate spade bag outlethttp://www.katespade-diaperbag.nethttp://www.katespadefactory.orghttp://www.katespadehandbags-outlet.netkate spade diaper bagkate spade bags outlethttp://www.katespade-outletonline.netkate spade purseskate spade salehttp://www.katespadesurprisesale.comkate spade totehttp://www.katespadeukoutlet.comhttp://www.katespade-usa.orglouis vuitton handbagshttp://www.louisvuitton-christmas.comLouis Vuitton clutch purseLouis Vuitton Bagscheap louis vuitton bagslouis vuitton walletsLouis Vuitton HandbagsLouis Vuitton Handbags outletlouis vuitton outlethttp://www.louisvuitton--outletstore.netLouis Vuitton Bagshttp://www.louisvuitton-plazabags.comlouis vuitton storehttp://www.louisvuittonstore2015.comLouis Vuitton Outlet onlinehttp://www.louisvuittonsunglassess.netmichael kors jet set totehttp://www.michaelkors-mk.orghttp://www.michaelkorsmkbags.nethttp://www.michaelkorsmkoutlet.orgmichael kors purseshttp://www.michaelkorsmkwallet.commichael kors outlet online salemicheal korshttp://www.mkfactoryoutlet.netmk bags outlethttp://www.mkmichaelkorsfactoryoutlet.comhttp://www.mkmichaelkorshandbags.nethttp://www.mkmichaelkorspurses.commk bag ukmk outlet onlinenike air huarachesauthentic nike air jordan shoeshttp://www.nikeairmax1essential.comhttp://www.nikeairmax1in2014.comhttp://www.nikeairmax90classic.com

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • No HTML tags allowed
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.